Showing posts with label Medieval. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medieval. Show all posts

Wednesday, 10 February 2021

Types of Reasoning According to Averroes

People have different levels of ability, according to Averroes (d. 1198). They belong broadly to the demonstrative class, the dialectical class and the rhetorical class. These 3 classes correspond to the 3 types of reasoning, demonstrative, dialectical and rhetorical. 



 

 

 

Ockham’s Connectedness of Virtues

William of Ockham (d. 1347) posits that moral virtue is an ethically-charged habit caused by moral acts that inclines or disposes us to perform similar acts. It is a feedback loop of acts leading to habits leading to further acts which then further reinforces the habit. This is contrary to the Independence of Act-Opportunity Principle where even if we have the opportunity to have one virtue, say temperance, it does not mean we will have the opportunity for other virtues such as justice. The act-opportunities are independent of one another. Since habits come from doing an act, if we never have the chance to act justly, then according to this principle, we will not be able to develop the virtue of justice, since no opportunities to act justly will mean no acts of justice. No acts of justice mean we do not form the habit of being just, leading to not acquiring the virtue of being just.

How We Learn, According to Augustine

According to Augustine (d. 430), we do not learn about the things themselves through words, since if we did not already know what words like green, room and cabinet mean, the word will not teach it to us. However, words do have a function – they prompt us by directing our attention to “remind us to look for things.” (The Teacher, p. 137, l. 170) We have to be prompted, to compare what we have been told, to consult our “inner light” (p. 140, l. 31), that is, God, to make the judgement if what is told is true. 



Thursday, 6 February 2020

Are Intermediaries Needed in Cognition?

In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth,[1] the Bible tells us in the opening verse of the first book of Genesis, which narrates the literal genesis of the universe. In another book of the Bible, the Gospel of John, written thousands of years later to chronicle the epochal event of the Christian faith, the life of Jesus, a similar phrase was used, no less poetic and awe-inspiring but somewhat more opaque: In the beginning was the Word.[2] What was the relationship between God, his Son and the Word? Augustine of Hippo answers this question in De Trinitate. According to Panaccio, Augustine’s main idea is that in order to understand the Trinity, the human mind needs to be examined since human beings are made in God’s image,[3] and hence the “spiritual part of man must be the best image there is among all creatures of the Divine essence.”[4] For Augustine, the relation between God and his Son is like the relation of the mind and the mental word. The mental word is expressed externally by the spoken word, just like how the God is expressed to the world by an incarnation which is Jesus. [5]